If you’re involved in drafting or pitching op-eds for a college or university president, this blogpost is for you.
Recently we launched a searchable database of such opinions published in major national outlets since fall 2016. The database currently includes nearly 500 op-eds. Having read them all, we’d like to share several realities that are worth considering if you want to give all your hard work on op-eds the best chance of seeing the light of day:
1. BE TIMELY
It’s no surprise that if a topic is dominating national news, editors will be interested in the higher-education angle. This was obvious during, for example, the intense debate about the Trump administration’s immigration policies, when presidents found an audience for numerous related opinions, from protecting DACA students to learning from those with whom we may disagree to scaring off future Einsteins.
Of course the impact of COVID-19 gets editors’ attention now, and a slew of related presidential pieces have emerged, including how the pandemic has undermined the foundation of our educational system, how to support students while campuses are closed, and opportunities to improve higher education beyond the crisis.
2. PAY LEADERSHIP FORWARD
Editors’ interest is clear: the database already includes nearly 100 articles in which presidents offer tips and insights into the weighty issues that come with being at the helm. These include commentaries on everything from coping with scandals and prioritizing mental health to achieving faculty diversity and creating leadership pathways for women. There’s even a president’s wish list to Santa. What has your president learned lately that can be shared?
3. PICK A HOT BUTTON
Campuses are in many ways testing grounds for antagonisms boiling in our culture. If your president is willing to publish a strong opinion on a topic that is drawing heat (although that is far easier said than done when the diverse constituencies of campuses are reading), editors may well bite. In recent years, for example, as controversial speakers and related campus protests have fueled debates about the First Amendment, presidents have opined on how to protect students’ rights and ensure student safety, and offered a free-speech checklist to help prepare for events that can go awry.
4. COUNT ON COST QUESTIONS
Is college worth the investment? This question isn’t going anywhere. Actually, it promises to be even more controversial—which likely means of editorial interest—as fall planning takes shape in the coming months. Published presidents have taken the cost question head on, considered the value of education beyond price, and wondered what happens if public support keeps declining.
Kitchen-table issues like this get attention, as do more sophisticated versions (Ph.D.-kitchen-table issues, if you will), like these: research supports the intellectual and societal value of higher education and the economics of college degrees.
5. HUMANIZE THE STUDENT EXPERIENCE
News outlets know that America’s 20 million college students represent a lot of potential readers. Some presidents have gotten personal, sharing what it was like to trade places with a student for a day or move into a first-year dorm. Others have reflected on their time exploring student views on “impractical humanities courses” and how to choose a major.
Those last types of commentaries are less likely to wade into controversy’s midst. But the database shows that if your president is willing to do that, the axiom is true: conflict is interesting.
Sources:
From Anger to Action for Dreamers, September 8, 2017 in Inside Higher Ed by Patricia McGuire for Trinity Washington University
A liberal education includes learning from people with whom one disagrees, February 1, 2017 in Inside Higher Ed by Michael S. Roth for Wesleyan University
We’re scaring off future Einsteins, March 17, 2017 in USA Today by James Harris for University of San Diego
How Should Colleges Prepare for a Post-Pandemic World?, April 13, 2020 in The Chronicle of Higher Ed by Brian Rosenberg for Macalester College
Supporting our students during campus closures, April 8, 2020 in University Business by Joseph I. Castro for California State University Fresno
It’s Time To Take Time Out Of Learning And Reinvent Higher Education, May 3, 2020 in Forbes by Paul LeBlanc for Southern New Hampshire University
What to Do When It’s Your Crisis, January 26, 2018 in The Chronicle of Higher Ed by James C. Garland for Miami University of Ohio
Mental health should be among colleges’ ‘most urgent priorities’, October 25, 2019 in Education Dive by Shirley Collado for Ithaca College
Incentivizing Faculty Diversity, January 20, 2020 in Inside Higher Ed by Katherine Newman for University of Massachusetts Boston
Creating leadership pathways for women in higher ed, January 8, 2019 in Education Dive by Carolyn Stefanco for The College of Saint Rose
A college president’s letter to Santa, 2017, December 17, 2017 in Huffington Post by Scott D. Miller for Virginia Wesleyan University
Messy but Essential, November 20, 2017 in Inside Higher Ed by Ana Mari Cauce for University of Washington
Free Speech, Campus Safety, or Both, September 15, 2017 in The Chronicle of Higher Ed by Mark G. Yudof for University of California
A Free-Speech To-Do List for College Administrators, September 4, 2017 in The Wall Street Journal by Howard Gillman for University of California at Irvine
Helping students believe college is ‘worth the investment’, October 25, 2018 in Education Dive by M. Duane Nellis for Ohio University
Value matters in choosing a college. But not just the price kind., July 13, 2018 in The Washington Post by Jim Troha for Juniata College
Sharpening the Case for American Higher Education, August 9, 2017 in Huffington Post by Brian C. Mitchell for Bucknell University
Congress Needs To Follow The Research And Prioritize Higher Education, May 29, 2018 in Forbes by Kim Cassidy for Bryn Mawr College
Educating the public on the value of a college degree, May 7, 2017 in The Chronicle of Higher Ed by Molly Corbett Broad for American Council on Education
Trading Places, December 21, 2017 in Inside Higher Ed by Susan West Engelkemeyer for Nichols College
Moving into the freshman dorm, 44 years later., September 11, 2018 in The Washington Post by David A. Thomas for Morehouse College
Please, students, take that ‘impractical’ humanities course. We will all benefit., September 14, 2018 in The Washington Post by Ronald J. Daniels for Johns Hopkins University
How A College Major Might Be Minor, February 28, 2019 in Forbes by Sian Beilock for Barnard College